Friday, July 26, 2024

July data to ascertain real impact of diesel rationalisation

Together with his "bodoh" and "bangang" remark, Rafizi Ramli's smirk as he hinted of a surprise on the RON 95 rationalisation plan during the Sungai Bakap by-election campaign may have cost PKR an embarassing loss.

Anwar had to immediately deny of an immediate plan for RON 95 and few days ago, he reiterated again with the excuse the impact of the diesel rationalisation need to be ascertain. A Bank report claimed a faster-than-expected growth allowed for the postphonement

So this blog will look into it the impact as well. 

According to Finance Minister II, Dato Seri Amir Hamzah Azizan, the diesel rationalisation managed to reduce leakage by 25% or 6.5 million litre daily for June figure. 

The leakages were due to smuggling activities and misappropriation by industries. Highlighting this was the 50% drop in sales by petrol stations near the northern border.  

On July 16, Deputy Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister Fuziah Salleh denied claim by MP for Hulu Terengganu, Datok Rosol Wahid to blame diesel rationalisation for price increase. 

She informed Parliament that there was no unusual price increase for the 418 daily necessities montored by the National Price of Goods Division since the commencement of diesel subsidy rationalisation on June 10. 

Fuziah rebutted Rosol's attempt to twist a question by associating diesel rationalisation with other non-related factors as reason driving investors away. Proves PN politicians are not aware of the latest development on the economic front.

However, to quote from the Star Online today:

CGS International (CGSI) Research said the impact of diesel price hike could be seen in July data and it may be too early to assess the second-round impact of the diesel price hike using June CPI data.

To recap, diesel prices were raised from RM2.15 per litre to RM3.35 per litre overnight on June 10, 2024 as part of a subsidy re-targeting measures.

“The direct impact was clearly seen in the transport component, where an increase of 0.5% m-o-m was recorded in June (diesel constitutes 0.2% of the CPI basket).

“Yet, the impact on related components such as transport services or fresh foods is not yet obvious,” it said in a report.

CGSI Research said another component to watch for is June producer price index, to be released on July 29, which may provide an early indication of the possible pass-through impact of the diesel price hike on other CPI components.

The research outfit expects price pressures to remain strong in the second half of 2024 (2H24), partially due to a low base following stronger macro data from the consumption side such as retail sales and imports of consumption goods.

There seem to be no disagreement on the upside possibility in the price of goods, but contrary to the fear and panic depicted on social media, there are economists and analysts who felt situation is manageable. 

Star Online wrote yesterday: 

Impact of diesel subsidy removal manageable

By KIRENNESH NAIR

ECONOMY

Thursday, 25 Jul 2024

Associate professor Liew said Malaysia’s current inflation levels suggest a stable, yet cautious, economic environment.

PETALING JAYA: Malaysia experienced a 2% inflation rate in June, consistent with May’s rate, bringing the average inflation rate for the first half of 2024 (1H24) to 1.82%.

The consumer price index (CPI) stood at 133.0, up from 130.4 in the same month the previous year.

According to the Statistics Department, restaurant and accommodation services saw the largest year-on-year increase at 3.3%, slightly higher than May’s 3.2%, primarily due to higher costs in the beverage preparation services sub-group.

Inflation for housing, water, electricity, gas, and other fuels remained steady at 3.2%, driven mainly by the water supply and miscellaneous dwelling services subgroups.

Food and beverage prices increased by 2% in June, compared with a significant 18% in May.

The main food sub-group rose by 0.9%, up from 0.5% in the previous month.

However, the increase in the main subgroup of food away from home slowed slightly to 3.3% from 3.4% in May.

Inflation in the transport category recorded an increase of 1.2% in June 2024 as compared to May’s 0.9%.

This increase was contributed by the main sub-group of operation of personal transport equipment, which increased to 1.7% in June compared to 1.4% in May.

The expenditure class of fuels and lubricants for personal transport equipment increased to 0.9% as against 0.3% in May.

The Statistics Department noted that the increase aligned with the rise in the average price of unleaded petrol RON97, which averaged about RM3.47 per litre compared with RM3.37 in the corresponding month last year, and diesel in Peninsular Malaysia, which rose to RM2.99 per litre from RM2.15 per litre in June 2023.

To note, starting June 10, the retail price of diesel for Peninsular Malaysia was set at RM3.35 per litre compared with RM2.15 per litre, while the retail price of diesel in Sabah, Sarawak and Wilayah Persekutuan Labuan remained at RM2.15 per litre.

Following the implementation of diesel subsidy rationalisation, concerns about inflation have surged, particularly regarding its potential impact on transportation costs and broader consumer prices.

Economists, however, opined that while the subsidy rationalisation may exert some upward pressure on inflation, its overall impact will be moderated by targeted measures and continued support for key sectors.

They argued that effective management and strategic interventions will be crucial in stabilising the economy and ensuring that the long-term benefits of the subsidy reforms outweigh any immediate challenges.

Economist Geoffrey Williams emphasised that most companies eligible for subsidised diesel would continue to pay the old price, thus mitigating any significant increase in costs.

“People must be vigilant to make sure companies are not using subsidy rationalisation as an excuse to raise prices,” he added.

Meanwhile, UCSI University Malaysia associate professor of finance Liew Chee Yoong said the subsidy rationalisation programme for diesel is likely to create upward pressure on prices, particularly in 2H24, potentially pushing inflation to between 2% and 3.5% for the year.

For perspective, if the country were to achieve a full-year inflation rate of 2.8%, the CPI in 2H24 would need to average about 3.78%, over double its average in 1H24.

Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd chief economist Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid said while the direct impact on the CPI might be minimal – since diesel represents only 0.2% of the total CPI – “the risks of higher inflation are not negligible.”

He noted that business pricing behaviours could influence the overall inflation outlook.

Sellers might raise prices and attribute it to the diesel price hike, leveraging the subsidy changes to justify increased costs, thereby echoing the pricing concerns voiced by Williams, although the actual impact on CPI is relatively small.

Inflation in June 2024 was influenced by a 3.3% and 3.2% year-on-year increase in both the restaurant and accommodation services, as well as housing, utilities, gas, and other fuels categories, respectively.

When asked if the trends are likely to persist, Mohd Afzanizam said: “I believe so. Adjustment on the services tax rate from 6% to 8%, electricity subsidy rationalisation, as well as water tariff adjustment, has resulted in an upward increase in these prices.”

However, he said measures such as higher cash transfer programmes like Rahmah Cash Aid and Sumbangan Asas Rahmah for poor households, along with targeted subsidies, are expected to minimise the impact.

“Not to mention the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) Flexible Account withdrawals would also help to mitigate the impact among EPF members from higher cost of living,” he added.

Similarly, Liew said the trends observed in June 2024, where inflation rose by 2% year-on-year, are likely to persist.

“These sectors continue to experience demand pressures and cost-push inflation due to higher utility and energy prices. If these trends continue, the broader economy could face challenges such as reduced consumer purchasing power and increased costs for businesses, potentially slowing economic growth,” he added.

Conversely, Williams said the increase in utility prices would gradually taper off, but warned that sectors like hotel restaurants and food outlets are “notorious for passing on costs to customers,” which could influence overall price levels.

However, overall, Williams acknowledged that inflation is being handled well by Bank Negara and hence, he expects it to hover around or below historical levels of between 1.9% and 2% for the year.

Liew, on the other hand, said Malaysia’s current inflation levels, hovering around 1.8% to 3%, depending on the sector, suggest a stable yet cautious economic environment.

To better manage inflation and support economic stability, he suggested implementing measures such as targeted subsidies for essential goods, boosting support for local food production to reduce reliance on imports, and enhancing energy efficiency programmes to mitigate utility cost increases.

“Additionally, maintaining a balanced fiscal policy that does not overly strain public finances while providing necessary economic support will be crucial,” he added.

Mohd Afzanizam, meanwhile, said the projected inflation rate of between 2% and 3.5% for 2024 reflects the degree of uncertainty in respect of the policy changes and the impact on overall inflation.

“It is safe to say that the balance of risks for inflation is tilted to the upside. While this affects consumer and business sentiments, these measures (subsidy rationalisation and higher taxes) are necessary to improve the government finances which can be redirected towards economic development such as education, healthcare, and infrastructure,” he said.

This is all good from the macro outlook, but for the common folks, any minor increase has significant impact on their spending ability.

Over breakfast with a rural-based politician recently, he shared the lament of housewives in his areas awaiting for the availability of Rahmah rice to replenish their stock. 

The increase of 5 kilo rice from RM25 to RM41 seemed petty for the urban and still within affordabolity, but to the rubber tapper, that increase is equivalent to few days of laborious work. 

That is only a single food item of rice.  

No comments: